Most Viewed

Top 6 articles this week:

Top Rated

Top 5 recent articles:

Advertisement

Current Articles | Categories | Search | Syndication

Emory study: Pot-smoking connected with early mental illness

 


By Christine Foster

A 1980s anti-drug-abuse campaign told U.S. schoolchildren to “just say no” to drugs. However, not all of them do; many of them grow up to say “yes.” Quite a few of them begin a longtime drug habit by trying a gateway drug, usually marijuana.

But according to a new Emory University-led study, marijuana may be a gateway to more than just the use of other drugs—it may also accelerate mental illness.

The study, funded by the National Institute of Mental Health and published in the November issue of the American Journal of Psychiatry, finds that patients being treated for psychosis who had a history of smoking cannabis or “pot” on a daily basis experienced psychotic and pre-psychotic symptoms at earlier ages than those who did not.

Researchers at Emory and Georgia State University analyzed data from 109 hospitalized patients. A review of each patient’s symptoms and in-depth drug history showed first-time psychosis patients were more likely to experience psychotic disorders at much younger ages if they had a history of using marijuana daily.

“The purpose [of the study] was to evaluate a group of young people, aged 18 to 40 years, who were hospitalized for the first evaluation and treatment of a psychotic disorder like schizophrenia,” says Dr. Michael T. Compton of Emory’s Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences department. “We wanted to determine if an adolescent’s marijuana use, before the onset of their symptoms, may have hastened their disorder, causing it to appear earlier than it would have otherwise.”

Prior studies by other researchers have also suggested that marijuana may trigger an early onset of psychotic symptoms.

“Having a family history of psychosis is also associated with an earlier onset on average,” says Compton, whose primary area of research is schizophrenia.

Another factor associated with an early onset of psychosis is gender. Typically, males who smoke pot daily see psychotic symptoms begin between 18 and 25, and females experience their first symptoms between 25 and 32, says Compton.

The symptoms can include delusional thoughts and hallucinations, such as thinking a government agency is tracking them or hearing voices that do not exist. Compton says the new study provides more supporting data.

“For someone who [already] has a hidden genetic risk for developing schizophrenia, using marijuana—especially heavy use that escalates to a daily basis—may cause an earlier onset [of psychotic disorders],” he says. “This is problematic, because the earlier the disease starts, the poorer the outcome is, on average.”

Dr. Timothy Fong, an assistant clinical professor of psychiatry and director of the Impulse Control Disorders Clinic at the University of California at Los Angeles, also warns that marijuana has been associated with the worsening of mental illnesses.

“Marijuana has never been shown to help these psychiatric problems over time and there is a mountain of research to show that if you smoke marijuana now, then your psychiatric problems are not likely to get better on their own,” Fong writes on the Web site Above the Influence (www.abovetheinfluence.com). ”Actually, they are more likely to get worse.”

The site states that marijuana is addictive, “with more teens in treatment with a primary diagnosis of marijuana dependence than for all other illicit drugs combined,” and has been identified as a factor in learning disabilities, anxiety and panic attacks, and shortened attention span.
Emory’s Compton offers a similar array of negatives.

“First and foremost, the use of marijuana can be associated with a multitude of problem behaviors,” he says, including problems in school and school drop-out rates as well as respiratory system difficulties. And, he says, his research shows that it may cause an earlier onset of psychiatric illnesses in those who are already at risk.

The scariest part, says Compton, is young pot users “usually don’t know that they are at risk.” SP
Rating:

In this report is does validate a few things for me, one being marijuana is a gateway drug and the various other ways it affects people. One thing that was not mentioned and happens to be fact is, marijauna does burn up nutrients in the body that can directly affect a person moodsand behaviors, it also affects the neurobalance of the brain and the way it functions. This study does not appear to have taken these into consideration. These affects can mimic psyschiatric disorders and should be considered. For more information please take a look at www.addictionwatch.com

BNewman
Monday, December 21, 2009 at 1:18 AM


John,

I deleted your posts because you were making potentially dangerous claims--dangerous in terms of how misleading they are for young people whose health could be harmed by them. You made these claims with no scientific proof and no links to any of the studies that you vaguely mentioned (you basically just said "lots of studies" or "many studies" without ever linking to one). And in your latest post you link to druglibrary.com which is a paid marketing site, not a credible source.
I don't know what Bobby (above) is talking about, but at least he's not pretending to be an expert and he does actually give a rehab site that people can link to.
Dr. Compton at Emory is a real researcher. He's not basing his information on any kind of political stance or your (paranoid?) conspiracy theory about "prohibs." He and his team looked at existing medical files and saw a pattern: people with a family history of mental illness who smoked pot on a regular basis in their youth were more likely to see an earlier onset of mental illness. Period. That's what they found and that is what they are reporting.
The fact that you are so angry that scientists would dare to report this link between teen pot-smoking and early-onset mental illness says everything about you and nothing whatsoever in support of your alleged "arguments."
If you want to smoke pot, go toke up to your heart's content, but at least have the common sense to acknowledge that there are downsides to marijuana just as there are to alcohol, tobacco, caffiene, steroids, anti-depressants, weight loss medication and so on. -- Stephanie Ramage

Stephanie Ramage
Sunday, December 27, 2009 at 2:31 PM


Stephanie

Thanks for the post. Most people who engage in censorship won't give that consideration. If you will be so kind, please consider my responses.

>>>"I deleted your posts because you were making potentially dangerous claims--dangerous in terms of how misleading they are for young people whose health could be harmed by them."

I'm sorry, but that's not true. I have been studying this issue for forty years. I promise I know what I'm talking about.

>>>"You made these claims with no scientific proof and no links to any of the studies that you vaguely mentioned (you basically just said "lots of studies" or "many studies" without ever linking to one)."

That's because this was an initial post, meant to get the conversation started. If I had provided the references for every point, the post would be pages long. Any point you have a question about, I will gladly provide the scientific proof to back up.

>>>"And in your latest post you link to druglibrary.com which is a paid marketing site, not a credible source."

Uh-oh. Here's a problem. You call it a "paid marketing site." Most sites on the web have advertising, including this one. That's really a non-point. If you really want to criticize the information, you must show that it is not valid. Instead, you just make a lame attack on the source. The link I gave was directly to the major government studies. This site has the most complete collection of these studies on the Internet. Some colleges use this site as part of their curriculum. It is crucial reading for anyone who wants to be educated on this subject.

>>>"I don't know what Bobby (above) is talking about, but at least he's not pretending to be an expert and he does actually give a rehab site that people can link to."

I'm not pretending either, of course. Just address any point you wish, and I can demonstrate it as often as you like.

>>>"Dr. Compton at Emory is a real researcher. He's not basing his information on any kind of political stance or your (paranoid?) conspiracy theory about "prohibs."

I showed in my post how Emory's "research" is totally political. This is nothing new. There is much skewed research and junk science sponsored by prohibitionists. NIDA's whole mission is to conjure up this kind of trash to dump on marijuana. It's not a "conspiracy theory." Dr. Compton is a young "addiction specialist." Many of these "specialists" see the vast numbers of marijuana consumers and salivate about the many millions of potential customers. Never mind marijuana is NOT addictive. At its core, addiction involves withdrawal symptoms that are so severe, addicts continue use to avoid the discomfort/pain. Marijuana has no such withdrawal symptoms.

>>>"He and his team looked at existing medical files and saw a pattern: people with a family history of mental illness who smoked pot on a regular basis in their youth were more likely to see an earlier onset of mental illness. Period."

In science, nothing is ever "period." Science is a process that is continuously unfolding. There are many factors that can skew this kind of junk "research." One is it's likely these youth were self-medicating with cannabis. But mostly, arguing against use of marijuana by teens is a straw man argument. That is, NO ONE is saying teens should smoke pot. Recreational drugs are an adult activity. I'd be willing to bet that youth who drank alcohol on a regular basis suffer far worse mental - AND definitely physical problems.

>>>"have the common sense to acknowledge that there are downsides to marijuana just as there are to alcohol, tobacco, caffiene, steroids, anti-depressants, weight loss medication and so on."

This illustrates what drives most prohibitionist perspectives. They just assume that because other recreational drugs have great dangers, marijuana must also. But this is not the case. The only problem is with children/teens who consume. But it is prohibition that PUTS marijuana into kids hands, just like it did with alcohol prohibition. For adults, marijuana is remarkably benign.

As the DEA's own administrative law judge, Francis Young, concluded after an exhaustive review of the evidence, "Marijuana, in its natural state, is one of the safest therapuetically active substances known to man."

I welcome any rational discussion on any of the points I have made.

JohnThomas
Sunday, December 27, 2009 at 4:23 PM


You must be logged in to post a comment. You can log in here.

The Sunday Paper actively moderates site content.
Offensive material will be removed.
However, user comments on display do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Sunday Paper or its staff.

 
Advertisement